In Mount Gambier, a town built over caves, a collapsed cave became a public garden. What a hole in the ground can teach a city about the land it stands on.

On the first day of 2023 I stood at the edge of a hole in the ground in Mount Gambier, in South Australia, and looked down into a garden.

Mount Gambier is built on limestone, and limestone dissolves. Over a very long time, rainwater carves caves through it, and sometimes the roof of a cave falls in. What is left is a sinkhole: a round, steep-sided hole, open to the sky. The country around the town is full of them, and of caves.
Umpherston Sinkhole is one of these collapsed caves, right at the edge of town. In the 1880s a settler named James Umpherston, who owned the land, decided not to fence it off but to plant it. He made a sunken garden with terraces down its sides and a lawn on its floor. After his time it was neglected for decades, until the town council restored it. Today it is a free public garden, open to anyone who walks in.
Into the hole
You go down by paths that wind across the terraces. The walls rise around you, hung with curtains of ivy. At the bottom are tree ferns, hydrangeas and lawn. The noise of the town disappears, the air feels cooler and damper, and when you look up there is only a ragged circle of sky.




It is one of the greenest places I have ever been, and it is green because of the hole, not in spite of it. The walls shelter the garden from the wind and shade it for much of the day. Water drains into it. The plants on the floor live in a small climate of their own, a little like the shaded floor of a forest.


Sinkhole urbanism
Most cities treat a sinkhole as a disaster: something to fill, fence and forget. Mount Gambier did the opposite. It took the one piece of ground that could never be built on and made it the most loved garden in town.
I think there is a lesson in that for every city. The best open spaces are often the places the ground itself has set aside: the steep valley, the floodplain, the river bank, the hole where a cave fell in. They are dangerous to build on and expensive to fix. They are cheap to keep and easy to plant. A city that maps its ground first, and leaves those places for nature and for people, gets its parks almost for free.

Underneath the garden, the limestone is still there, and the water is still at work. One day there will be other holes. If the town is wise, it will plant those too.
Images: Archigardener, unless otherwise stated.



